What is PCB Delamination?
PCB delamination is a serious defect that can occur in printed circuit boards where the layers separate or come apart. It is sometimes referred to as PCB blistering since delaminated areas often appear raised like a blister on the board’s surface.
Printed circuit boards are manufactured by laminating together multiple layers of thin copper foil separated by insulating material, typically fiberglass. Heat and pressure are applied to bond the layers together into a single rigid board. Delamination happens when this bond fails and the layers detach from each other.
Common causes of PCB delamination include:
– Moisture ingress
– Thermal stress from soldering
– Mechanical stress during depaneling
– Contamination between layers
– Manufacturing defects
– Inferior materials
Impact of Delamination on PCBs
Delamination compromises the structural integrity and reliability of the printed circuit board. An air gap forms in the delaminated area, potentially breaking electrical connections. This can lead to intermittent failures or complete malfunction of the circuit.
The defect is problematic because it may not be immediately apparent. A board can pass initial electrical testing but delaminate later from thermal or mechanical stress. Field failures related to delamination are difficult to diagnose.
Blistering exposes the board to further damage as well. The separated layers are no longer protected from moisture, chemicals, or debris that can cause corrosion or short circuits. Delamination often starts small but propagates with heat cycling, leading to catastrophic failure.
Causes of PCB Delamination
Several factors related to PCB design, manufacturing, and operating conditions can contribute to delamination. Understanding the primary causes helps with preventing this defect.
Moisture
Moisture is a significant cause of delamination, especially in non-hermetic environments. PCB substrate materials are somewhat hygroscopic and absorb atmospheric humidity. If boards are stored for long periods before soldering, the absorbed moisture vaporizes rapidly when exposed to soldering temperatures around 240°C.
The expanding water vapor generates pressure between the layers that can overcome the adhesive bond strength. Blistering occurs as the gas forces the layers apart. Delamination caused by moisture tends to be more widespread across the board compared to thermally-induced failures.
IPC standards specify maximum acceptable moisture levels in PCBs before assembly. Baking PCBs prior to soldering effectively removes moisture. However, if the bake out is insufficient or skipped, the risk of delamination increases significantly.
Thermal Stress
Thermal stresses during assembly are another major cause of PCB delamination. The coefficients of thermal expansion (CTE) for copper, fiberglass, and bonding materials differ. Temperature changes cause the PCB Layers to expand and contract at different rates.
Repeated or rapid heating and cooling cycles induce shear stresses between the layers. The adhesive bond can deteriorate and fail over time. Delamination often initiates around Plated Through Holes where the mismatch strain is highest.
Wave soldering and solder dipping subject the entire board to thermal shock. Reflow soldering of surface mount components also generates heat that penetrates into the board. Designs requiring multiple high temperature processes increase the cumulative stress on the PCB laminate.
Mechanical Stress
Mechanical stresses during PCB fabrication and assembly can cause delamination. Shear and bend forces applied to the board create tension between the layers that can pull them apart. Mechanical delamination frequently occurs along the board edges.
Routing, drilling, and depaneling processes generate mechanical stress. Dull router bits or improperly supported boards allow vibrations and flexing that promote delamination. V-scoring depanelization concentrates the stress on a narrow region at the edge.
Contamination
Contamination entering between the PCB layers during manufacturing leads to delamination. The contaminant interferes with the adhesion of the bonding material. Delaminated areas typically appear around the foreign object trapped in the board.
Common PCB contaminants include:
– Particles like dust or fibers
– Chemicals such as flux, oil, or solvent residues
– Moisture from humid air or wet processes
– Inclusions or voids in the prepreg material
Careful control of the fabrication environment is essential to minimize contamination. Clean room protocols for sensitive processes help tremendously. Storing PCBs and materials in dry, sealed containers reduces moisture and particle exposure.
Manufacturing Defects
Deficiencies in the PCB manufacturing process are responsible for many delamination issues. Problems with the lamination press cycle, drill quality, and prepreg management frequently result in poor layer adhesion.
The lamination press applies heat and pressure to cure the prepreg resin and bond the layers. Insufficient temperature, pressure, or dwell time prevent proper fusion. Delamination can also occur if the press heats or cools too rapidly, inducing thermal stress.
Drilling through multilayer PCBs generates heat that can degrade the surrounding bond. Worn or incorrectly shaped drill bits increase the thermal load. Ineffective removal of the drill smear leaves an unstable surface for the next lamination cycle.
Prepreg is the uncured bonding sheet used to laminate the layers. The resin must flow and fill the gaps between features. Prepregs that are too thin, expired, or stored improperly may lack sufficient resin to form a complete bond.
Inferior Materials
Using inferior materials to fabricate PCBs significantly increases the chance of delamination. Bonding the layers requires compatible prepreg and laminate properties. The glass transition temperature (Tg) and decomposition temperature (Td) must be high enough to withstand soldering.
Cheaper, lower quality base materials may have unacceptable amounts of moisture or contaminants. Improperly stored prepregs absorb humidity and degrade over time. If the resin is too old or exceeds the allowable moisture level, the risk of delamination rises.
Delamination can also result from poorly matched prepreg and laminate CTE values. The difference in thermal expansion between the layers introduces added stress. Larger mismatches make the board much more likely to delaminate with thermal cycling.
Detection Methods for PCB Delamination
Effective PCB delamination detection prevents defective boards from reaching assembly or being installed in the end product. Methods range from simple manual inspection to advanced ultrasonic imaging. Using multiple test methods improves detection of marginally delaminated boards.
Visual Inspection
Visual inspection is the most basic PCB delamination detection method. Trained technicians examine the board under appropriate lighting and magnification. They look for the characteristic raised appearance of delaminated regions, especially near the edges.
Careful visual inspection reliably detects severe delamination but less so for minor occurrences. Boards with small edge delamination may be missed, as the defect is not obvious. Improper lighting or inspector fatigue also reduce detection rates.
More advanced automated optical inspection (AOI) equipment improves the visual detection of PCB delamination. These computer vision systems capture high resolution images of the board surface. Machine learning algorithms analyze the images and identify suspected delaminated regions.
Thermography
Infrared thermography detects PCB delamination by observing the thermal signature of the board. A thermal imaging camera records the surface temperature profile after heating the PCB. Delaminated areas appear as hot spots because the air gap acts as an insulator, slowing heat transfer.
The thermography method works well for detecting large delaminations but has limited resolution. Small defects may not produce a clear thermal indication, especially if buried deep in the board. Thermography shows the lateral extent of delamination well but provides no information about the depth.
Ultrasonic Inspection
Ultrasonic inspection is a powerful method for detecting and characterizing PCB delamination. High frequency acoustic waves, typically 10-50 MHz, are pulsed into the board. Echoes from internal features and defects are analyzed to create a cross-sectional image.
Scanning acoustic microscopy (SAM) is commonly used for PCB Inspection. The ultrasonic transducer scans across the board, generating a 2D map showing the size and depth of delaminations. The scanning water tank fully immerses the PCB, effectively coupling the ultrasound.
Laser ultrasonic systems offer an alternative for inspecting boards that cannot be immersed. A pulsed laser thermally excites ultrasonic waves in the PCB surface. A laser interferometer detects the returning echoes to image internal features. The laser system provides micron-level resolution for detecting small near-surface delaminations.
X-Ray Inspection
X-ray inspection is sometimes used for PCB delamination detection, although less commonly than ultrasonics. The delamination appears as a dark area on the X-ray image due to the lower density air gap. Microfocus X-ray sources provide high resolution images capable of detecting fine defects.
The X-ray method has the advantage of imaging multilayer boards without interference from surface components. However, delaminations lack contrast on the X-ray image compared to metallic features like traces and vias. The limited contrast makes thin delaminations difficult to distinguish.
Prevention of PCB Delamination
Preventing PCB delamination requires attention to design, material selection, and manufacturing processes. Implementing best practices and inspecting boards prior to assembly significantly reduces the occurrence of this defect.
Design Considerations
Certain PCB design choices help minimize the risk of delamination. Reducing the number of layers and amount of copper lowers the shear stress in the board. Decreasing the aspect ratio of plated through holes also reduces the localized expansion mismatch that can initiate cracks.
Allow sufficient spacing between copper features to promote uniform resin fill during lamination. Whenever possible, orient traces perpendicular to the board edge to avoid creating planes that can propagate delamination. Minimize overall board size to reduce the magnitude of thermal expansion forces.
High layer count backplanes and other complex PCBs prone to delamination benefit from sequential lamination. The board is fabricated as several sub-assemblies which are then laminated together. Breaking the design into smaller symmetrical units balances copper and reduces stress.
Material Selection
Choosing high quality PCB materials is critical for preventing delamination. Select base laminates and prepregs that meet IPC-4101 specifications for glass transition temperature, decomposition temperature, and thermal expansion. Prefer materials with higher resin content for improved bonding.
Use prepregs that closely match the thermal expansion coefficient of the base laminate. This reduces the shear stress between layers during soldering and thermal cycling. Thicker prepregs provide more resin to fill around copper features for a strong bond.
Avoid using extremely high or low Tg materials in the same PCB, as they expand at different rates. If mixed materials are necessary, choose prepregs with intermediate properties to minimize CTE mismatch. Limit the use of thick copper layers that generate excessive expansion force.
Manufacturing Controls
Careful control of PCB manufacturing processes is essential for avoiding conditions that cause delamination. Lamination, drilling, and storage practices have a significant impact on the final board quality.
Lamination press cycle parameters must be optimized based on the material properties. Ramp rates, temperature, pressure, and dwell times should follow the material manufacturer’s recommendations. Vacuum assist lamination removes air and volatiles that could otherwise become trapped in the board.
Drill feeds and speeds must balance productivity with minimizing thermal stress on the PCB. Inspect and regrind drills regularly to maintain a sharp, clean cutting edge. Promptly remove any resin smear from drilled holes before the next lamination cycle.
Bake PCBs and prepregs before lamination to remove absorbed moisture. Store all materials in a dry environment sealed against humidity and contamination. Clean room protocols minimize particulates that could deposit on the board and cause delamination.
Inspection and Testing
A comprehensive inspection and testing plan for PCBs helps screen out delamination issues before assembly. Visually examine all panels for blistering, edge separation, or discoloration that could indicate delamination. Cross-section a sample of coupons to verify that the lamination bond meets IPC-6012 acceptance criteria.
Incorporate automated optical inspection after drilling, routing, and final fabrication. Program the AOI system to check for delamination in high risk areas such as board edges and around holes. Characterize any flagged anomalies with acoustic microscopy to determine the extent of the defect.
Perform thermal stress testing on PCB coupons or first articles to verify delamination resistance. Subject the samples to multiple solder float or reflow cycles. Inspect the coupons for induced delamination using acoustic microscopy or cross-sectioning.
FAQ
What is the difference between delamination and blistering?
Delamination and blistering both involve separation of the PCB layers but the terms have slightly different meanings. Delamination refers to any planar splitting within the board, often occurring deeper in the stackup. Blistering is a more severe form of delamination that typically starts at the surface and appears as a raised area resembling a bubble. The two terms are often used interchangeably.
Can you repair a delaminated PCB?
Repairing a delaminated PCB is generally not practical or cost-effective. The split layers rarely bond back together properly, leaving the board vulnerable to future failures. Filling the void with epoxy may stabilize the area but does not restore the electrical integrity. If delamination is caught before soldering, the board can sometimes be reworked by spot lamination of the defect. However, the reliability remains suspect. In most cases, delaminated PCBs should be scrapped and replaced.
How much delamination is acceptable?
Most PCB specifications allow a small amount of delamination within defined limits. IPC-6012 permits some delamination around edges and unsupported holes, but not extending into the board. Acceptance depends on the board class, with Class 3 assemblies being the most stringent. In general, any delamination that impacts electrical performance, solder joints, or long-term reliability is rejectable.
What environmental conditions promote PCB delamination?
Exposure to high humidity and rapid temperature changes significantly increases the risk of PCB delamination. Moisture absorbed into the board vaporizes during soldering, potentially causing blistering. Temperature cycling generates shear stress between layers, weakening the adhesive bond over time. PCBs operating in uncontrolled environments with frequent moisture or thermal fluctuations are much more prone to delamination. Applying conformal coating to the assembly helps protect against humidity.
How do you control moisture in PCBs?
Proper storage and pre-bake procedures are key to controlling moisture in PCBs. Bare boards should be kept in sealed moisture barrier bags with desiccant to prevent humidity ingress. IPC standards define the maximum allowable moisture content prior to assembly based on the board thickness and reflow conditions. Pre-baking the PCBs at 125°C for 4-48 hours drives off absorbed water and ensures soldering will not cause delamination. Rebaking is necessary if the boards are stored too long before assembly.
0 Comments